My type changed between two tests a month apart. Did my personality change or was one of them wrong?
In June I got ENFP, last week I got INFP. Nothing major happened in between. It is bothering me more than it probably should — if the result can flip in a month, what was it measuring?
The answer
Answered by Fpsycal
Almost certainly neither. One of your four axes sat close to the middle, and a letter derived from a midpoint is a coin flip dressed up as a category.
Here is the mechanism. Traits like extraversion are distributed as one hump with most people in the middle — not as two clusters. A four-letter instrument cuts that hump at the midpoint and reports which side you landed on. If you score near the edge, the letter is stable and means something. If you score near the middle, two items answered differently on a different day moves you across the line, and the report gives you the new letter with exactly the same confidence as the old one. It never tells you which situation you were in, and that omission is the entire source of the confusion you are describing.
So E flipping to I most likely means your extraversion sits near the middle — which is a real and reportable finding about you, and a more accurate one than either letter. It means contact neither drains nor charges you reliably; it depends on who and how long. That is genuinely useful to know, and the code cannot express it.
One way to check: take a dichotomy scale that reports how far from the midpoint each axis sat, rather than only the letter. If E–I comes back at 48 and your other three are at 70-plus, you have your answer and you can stop wondering. Real personality change over a month does happen — after an illness, a bereavement, a move, a new medication — but it shows up as a shift in degree across several related things, not one letter swapping while everything else holds.
Checkable with: Four-Letter Type Preferences, Big Five Personality
Also from Fpsycal
Worth adding: the direction of your flip is the common one, and there is a mundane reason for it. E-to-I between two takes is often about the fortnight before each take rather than about you. Self-report items ask how you generally are, and people answer from what is recent and available — a busy social stretch pulls the answers one way, a quiet stretch pulls them back. That is not you being inconsistent, it is the instrument sampling a window.
If you want the version that does not have this problem, look for measures that are not asking you to summarise yourself: a task that records what you did, or a scale that asks about specific recent instances rather than general tendencies. And when you do retake something, note what the preceding two weeks looked like. If the letter tracks the fortnight, you have learned something more precise than a type.
Checkable with: Social Battery, Big Five Personality
Written by us rather than by a member, and not clinical advice. Where it rests on published research the answer says so, and where the evidence stops it says that too.
From the community
Loading…
Check it on yourself
Reading the answer and seeing your own numbers are different things. These are the assessments the answer above refers to.
Four-Letter Type Preferences
The four preference pairs behind every four-letter type, scored as gradients rather than cut at the middle. You get a letter and you get how close that letter was to flipping.
24 items · 5 min
Big Five Personality
The most validated model in personality psychology, rewritten as real-life scenarios. Measures Openness, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, Agreeableness, and Neuroticism.
44 items · 10 min
Social Battery
Where does your social energy come from and what drains it? Separates how quickly you deplete from what kind of contact restores you and from the depth you prefer.
18 items · 4 min
Related questions
Not the question you had? Ask yours.